Illegal, but right?!

Illegal says the High Court, but “right” says Attorney General Goldsmith:

It was of course uncomfortable… but I believe it was the right decision to take, in the public interest, in order to prevent terrorism.

I’m still trying to figure out what the hell we’re doing selling arms to the Saudi’s in the first place, let alone dealing in bribery and corruption, whilst protecting the interests of a private company.

It would have been a dereliction of duty to have taken that view and it would have been absolutely no comfort to people who, heaven forbid, had been injured or lost loved ones in a terrorist attack to say ‘we’re terribly sorry but we thought we ought to wait 18 months to see if this case could go ahead

This really is taking playing the terrorism card to a whole new low. The argument is essentially saying that the Saudi’s threatened to stop feeding us information on terrorist activity if the fraud investigation into the BAE affair carried on, ergo people will die in terrorist attacks.  What a load of bollocks.

Goldsmith is getting a bit too ready to leap in to defend the government’s highly unethical and frequently illegal foreign policy. It was Goldsmith who re-wrote his legal advice to suite Labour’s unstoppable lust for a war in Iraq; even though it would appear that he originally noted that it would, in fact, be illegal under international law.  He’s never had his legal judgement on that matter tried in court.  He has, however, had his legal judgement on the SFO investigation into BAe tested, and he was wrong.

I strongly suspect he was wrong about Iraq too.  Everyone else in Blair’s government was.

Advertisements

5 Responses to Illegal, but right?!

  1. pvsutton says:

    I don’t want to comment on Goldsmith’s position, but most of us can think of actions which we deem illegal, but morally correct – or at least – morally acceptable. The primary example, in my mind, is euthanasia – or, more straightforwardly, the murder of a terminally ill person, by their wishes, but carried out by their spouse. This counts as murder, as is thoroughly illegal. But many people might consider it right.

  2. armchairdissident says:

    True, and similarly there are actions which are legal, but immoral. But Goldsmith was not acting in his capacity as a private citizen, but in his capacity as the government’s lawyer. His job is not to advise the government of the morality of a given choice of action, but the legality.

  3. Hats And Caps|mens hats and caps|Hats And Caps Service…

    […]Illegal, but right?! « Armchair Dissident[…]…

  4. Internet Web Directory…

    […]Illegal, but right?! « Armchair Dissident[…]…

  5. accommodation in Alicante|accommodation in Alicante Spain|Alicante|Alicante accommodation|Alicante apartments|Alicante apartments for rent|Alicante apartments for sale|Alicante for sale|Alicante house|Alicante houses|Alicante houses for sale|Alicante…

    […]Illegal, but right?! « Armchair Dissident[…]…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: